Elon Musk testified for 3 long hours about his 'pedo guy' tweet
While testifying in U.S. District Court Tuesday, Elon Musk had to square off against one of his worst enemies: bureaucracy.
The Tesla CEO was subject to the sloth of the justice system as he answered painstaking questions from the other side and waited through legal challenges and process scuffles while testifying in a defamation lawsuit against him.
Musk is accused of defaming Vernon Unsworth, a member of the team that rescued the Thai boys' soccer team after they became trapped in a cave in July 2018.
After Unsworth insulted Musk's efforts to help while speaking on CNN, Musk tweeted that Unsworth was a "pedo guy," ostensibly accusing Unsworth of being a pedophile.
The result: a defamation lawsuit truly fit for our times.
Musk took the stand at around 1:20 p.m. Unsworth's lead counsel, a steely white-haired gentleman with a heavy Southern drawl, began taking Musk to task — very, very slowly.
The attorney's questioning didn't end until 4:45 p.m. Then, Musk's attorneys questioned him for an additional 15 minutes, promising — hooray — to resume the next day. All in, Musk was on the stand with a few breaks for over 3.5 hours.
Musk remained neutral over most of the testimony. But as time wore on, everyone — Musk, his attorneys, the jury, the gallery, the judge — began to crack. On more than one occasion, the process of admitting evidence sputtered when the judge failed to grasp the mechanics of Twitter and email threads. After multiple technical spars between the legal teams and the judge interrupted the already lethargic rhythm of questioning, Musk couldn't help but stretch, look around, and even roll his eyes in visible frustration at one of the later delays.
Tweet may have been deletedSEE ALSO:Elon Musk tells employees smoking weed with Joe Rogan was 'not wise'
Testifying in front of a jury for that long would be hard for anyone. But Elon Musk is not just anyone, and it was striking to watch him have to sit still and answer questions about his emails and tweets for over 3.5 hours. In addition to being a CEO who generally says and does what he wants, this is a man who finds the bureaucracy of government processes maddeningly contemptible, to say the least; who so hates wasting time commuting that he decided to take on "solving traffic" by starting a whole dang drilling company.
But Musk was not alone in his frustration. Even the judge, himself testudinal in appearance and demeanor, happened to agree.
"We've had a number of sidebars," the judge said, denying a request to approach the bench. "We just have to keep going."
"I assume he did not literally mean to sodomize me with a submarine ... Just as I didn't literally mean he was a pedophile, he didn't mean he wanted to shove a sub up my ass."
The pace and multiple delays indicated a tense courtroom environment in which the two sides attempted to tell very different stories about an outlandish chain of events.
Things got off to a bumpy start when Musk only begrudgingly conceded that he was a person with "influence." That skeptical, defensive, and sometimes bemused attitude continued as Unsworth's attorney pressed him on his knowledge of Unsworth, his involvement in the cave rescue mission, his response to Unsworth's diss, the 'pedo guy' thread, and Musk's apology and behavior thereafter. (That behavior involved hiring a private investigator, who ended up being a conman, to dig into Unsworth's past and see if there was any evidence of pedophilia Musk's team could leak to the press; indeed, there was not).
Tweet may have been deleted
Musk stuck to some clear talking points, though: that the tweet was in response to an "unprovoked attack" in which Unsworth accused Musk's good works during the rescue saga of being a PR stunt. He also said that the "pedo guy" phrasing did not literally mean that he thought Unsworth was a pedophile, just that he was a generally "creepy guy." He said that the insult was on the same figurative level as the insult Unsworth originally levied at him: that Musk could "stick his submarine where it hurts."
"I assume he did not literally mean to sodomize me with a submarine," Musk said. "Just as I didn't literally mean he was a pedophile, he didn't mean he wanted to shove a sub up my ass."
SEE ALSO:Elon Musk's comments on autism prove he should not podcastBut how figurative Musk's language was intended to be is in question. In the original insult Twitter chain, Musk called it "sus" (i.e. suspicious) that Unsworth, who is a UK expat, was living in Thailand. Musk also said in a response on Twitter that he would bet Unsworth being a pedophile was true. Plus, he engaged the services of a private detective (albeit a less than legitimate one), and ended up calling Unsworth a "child rapist" in an angry email to a BuzzFeed reporter. Yikes.
Musk's attorneys are trying to show his humanity: Musk teared up on the stand when asked about his childhood, saying "it was difficult." Musk's sleeker looking (and literally faster-talking) legal team seems poised to put up a good fight.
The trial, and Musk's testimony, continues Wednesday.
CORRECTION: Dec. 5, 2019, 2:01 p.m. EST
A previous version of this post used incorrect legal terminology to describe Vernon Unsworth's legal team. All references have been corrected.
-
“笋货”上市采购旺!清远西牛麻竹笋迎秋季尝鲜热China, Russia propose lifting some UN sanctions on N. Korea, US says not the timeThe Thursday Slatest newsletter.努力开拓区域市场 不断提升经营业绩共同推动雅安职工思想政治引领数智化发展工作做深做实Roger Federer came back from a twoThe Galaxy Note 8 finally competes with the iPhone where it countsHurricane Michael is set to grow stronger and pummel the Florida coastBest smart home deal: The Amazon Smart Thermostat is just $63.99Your selfies won't look like shit anymore with an Android phone
下一篇:50 Places to Eat and Drink Before You Die
- ·Haider all set for Paralympics Ceremony
- ·汕尾16个产品入围深圳消费帮扶“百强好产品”名单
- ·市人大常委会党组中心组举行“严以律己”集中学习研讨
- ·China, Russia propose lifting some UN sanctions on N. Korea, US says not the time
- ·Pakistan Cricket at crossroads after shock defeat at Pindi
- ·Emma Watson defends her 2014 comments about Beyoncé
- ·N. Korea could announce end to nuke talks later this month: think tank
- ·我市13家企业参加“川货全国行·长春站”活动
- ·Yes, big spiders are spreading in the U.S. No, they're not flying.
- ·汕尾16个产品入围深圳消费帮扶“百强好产品”名单
- ·Richard Posner clarifies his views on the Constitution.
- ·Militants kill 20 hostages in Bangladesh, spare those who could recite Quran.
- ·50 Places to Eat and Drink Before You Die
- ·The Thursday Slatest newsletter.
- ·漫画人生二十载,携手《南农》逐梦路
- ·一天太阳一天雨 一身尘土一身泥
- ·AirPods Pro 3 and AirPods 4 may get revealed at the Apple September event
- ·Rashford 1 UK govt 0: footballer forces change on child poverty
- ·Your selfies won't look like shit anymore with an Android phone
- ·Airstrikes reportedly kill 250 ISIS fighters in Iraq as coalition forces gain ground.
- ·Best smart home deals this week
- ·'Best in Germany': Bayern clinch eighth straight Bundesliga title
- ·YouTube has a surprising number of illegally streamed TV shows
- ·Amazon introduces new 'Instant Pickup' shopping for Prime members
- ·PS5 Pro: There are new whispers that the release date is fast approaching
- ·The Thursday Slatest newsletter.
- ·多措并举优治理 绘就幸福新图景
- ·US flies another reconnaissance plane amid tensions with N. Korea: aviation tracker
- ·The Thursday Slatest newsletter.
- ·护卫生命 368名医护人员挽袖献血
- ·Apple Intelligence is now a little easier to get outside the U.S.
- ·Sarri targets first Juventus trophy against former club Napoli
- ·胜扬天基因邀您关注2023中国种猪精液大赛!
- ·天然绿色放养,清远瑶家花邀您品鉴优质猪肉!
- ·SCOTUS: The courts implementing Project 2025, without Trump.
- ·US flies another reconnaissance plane amid tensions with N. Korea: aviation tracker