Judge rules against US women's football team in equal pay case
时间:2024-09-23 04:28:16 来源:American news
WASHINGTON:A federal judge dismissed the United States women's football team's bid for equal pay on Friday, rejecting claims the players had been underpaid in a crushing defeat for the reigning world champions.
In a 32-page ruling, Judge Gary Klausner of the US District Court for Central California in Los Angeles tossed the women's claim of pay discrimination, ruling in favour of the United States Soccer Federation (USSF).
Klausner did allow the women's case for unfair treatment in areas such as travel, housing and medical support to proceed to trial, set for June 16 in Los Angeles.
But the judge said the equal pay claims -- the central plank of the case -- had been dismissed because there was evidence the women had previously turned down an offer in the Collective Bargaining Agreement negotiations to be paid along the lines of the US men's team.
"The history of negotiations between the parties demonstrates that the WNT rejected an offer to be paid under the same pay-to-play structure as the MNT, and the WNT was willing to forgo higher bonuses for benefits, such as greater base compensation and the guarantee of a higher number of contracted players," Klausner wrote.
"Accordingly, plaintiffs cannot now retroactively deem their CBA (collective bargaining agreement) worse than the MNT CBA by reference to what they would have made had they been paid under the MNT's pay-to-play terms structure when they themselves rejected such a structure," he said.
'Shocked and disappointed'
The US women were left stunned by their defeat on the pay issue. The women had been seeking back pay of $66 million under the Equal Pay Act.
Prominent US women's team star Megan Rapinoe said after learning of the court's decision that the battle is not over.
"We will never stop fighting for EQUALITY," she wrote on Twitter.
A spokeswoman for the players reacted with dismay following Friday's ruling.
"We are shocked and disappointed with today's decision, but we will not give up our hard work for equal pay," spokeswoman Molly Levinson said.
"We are confident in our case and steadfast in our commitment to ensuring that girls and women who play this sport will not be valued as lesser just because of their gender.
"We have learned that there are tremendous obstacles to change; we know that it takes bravery and courage and perseverance to stand up to them."
USSF said Friday night it would continue to work with the women's program to grow the game in the United States.
"We look forward to working with the Women's National Team to chart a positive path forward and to grow the game both here at home and around the world," it said.
"We are committed to continuing that work to ensure our Women's National Team remains the best in the world."
The increasingly acrimonious lawsuit had taken a dramatic turn in March, when a filing by lawyers for the federation argued that US men's team players required a "higher level of skill based on speed and strength" than the women.
The filing triggered outrage amongst the women's players while influential sponsors such as Coca-Cola voiced disgust at the remarks.
USSF President Carlos Cordeiro later resigned following the uproar, with Rapinoe accusing the USSF of "blatant sexism" in its legal filings.
The US women, who clinched back-to-back World Cup wins with victory at last year's finals in France, had based their claim for back pay in the disparities between prize money distributed by FIFA at the men's and women's World Cups.
Germany's men won $35 million for their victory in the 2014 World Cup while France earned $38 million after triumphing in Russia in 2018.
The United States women, victors in the 2015 and 2019 World Cups, earned total prize money of $6 million over the two tournaments.
The USSF argued in court that between the years 2015-2019, the women actually were paid more money than the men on both a cumulative and an average per game basis.
During that period the women's national team received $24 million and an average of $220,747 per game while the men's team received payments of $18 million and $212,639 per game.
Under the current CBA, which was signed in 2017, more than half the women's team players receive an annual base salary of $167,000.
In a 32-page ruling, Judge Gary Klausner of the US District Court for Central California in Los Angeles tossed the women's claim of pay discrimination, ruling in favour of the United States Soccer Federation (USSF).
Klausner did allow the women's case for unfair treatment in areas such as travel, housing and medical support to proceed to trial, set for June 16 in Los Angeles.
But the judge said the equal pay claims -- the central plank of the case -- had been dismissed because there was evidence the women had previously turned down an offer in the Collective Bargaining Agreement negotiations to be paid along the lines of the US men's team.
"The history of negotiations between the parties demonstrates that the WNT rejected an offer to be paid under the same pay-to-play structure as the MNT, and the WNT was willing to forgo higher bonuses for benefits, such as greater base compensation and the guarantee of a higher number of contracted players," Klausner wrote.
"Accordingly, plaintiffs cannot now retroactively deem their CBA (collective bargaining agreement) worse than the MNT CBA by reference to what they would have made had they been paid under the MNT's pay-to-play terms structure when they themselves rejected such a structure," he said.
'Shocked and disappointed'
The US women were left stunned by their defeat on the pay issue. The women had been seeking back pay of $66 million under the Equal Pay Act.
Prominent US women's team star Megan Rapinoe said after learning of the court's decision that the battle is not over.
"We will never stop fighting for EQUALITY," she wrote on Twitter.
A spokeswoman for the players reacted with dismay following Friday's ruling.
"We are shocked and disappointed with today's decision, but we will not give up our hard work for equal pay," spokeswoman Molly Levinson said.
"We are confident in our case and steadfast in our commitment to ensuring that girls and women who play this sport will not be valued as lesser just because of their gender.
"We have learned that there are tremendous obstacles to change; we know that it takes bravery and courage and perseverance to stand up to them."
USSF said Friday night it would continue to work with the women's program to grow the game in the United States.
"We look forward to working with the Women's National Team to chart a positive path forward and to grow the game both here at home and around the world," it said.
"We are committed to continuing that work to ensure our Women's National Team remains the best in the world."
The increasingly acrimonious lawsuit had taken a dramatic turn in March, when a filing by lawyers for the federation argued that US men's team players required a "higher level of skill based on speed and strength" than the women.
The filing triggered outrage amongst the women's players while influential sponsors such as Coca-Cola voiced disgust at the remarks.
USSF President Carlos Cordeiro later resigned following the uproar, with Rapinoe accusing the USSF of "blatant sexism" in its legal filings.
The US women, who clinched back-to-back World Cup wins with victory at last year's finals in France, had based their claim for back pay in the disparities between prize money distributed by FIFA at the men's and women's World Cups.
Germany's men won $35 million for their victory in the 2014 World Cup while France earned $38 million after triumphing in Russia in 2018.
The United States women, victors in the 2015 and 2019 World Cups, earned total prize money of $6 million over the two tournaments.
The USSF argued in court that between the years 2015-2019, the women actually were paid more money than the men on both a cumulative and an average per game basis.
During that period the women's national team received $24 million and an average of $220,747 per game while the men's team received payments of $18 million and $212,639 per game.
Under the current CBA, which was signed in 2017, more than half the women's team players receive an annual base salary of $167,000.
-
Ford can make your Mustang Mach19 Places Dedicated to World Cup and Football History4 major Samsung products rumored for 2024打击非法捕捞行为 保护水生生物资源Flying spaghetti monster and unworldly life filmed in deep sea footage22 Toy Museums That Take Playthings SeriouslySpaceX launches moon lander, lands booster despite tough conditions12 Forests That Offer Chills and ThrillsTesla Robotaxis aren't coming in August, it seemsM3 MacBook 14 vs. M3 Pro MacBook 14
相关内容
- ·多措并举优治理 绘就幸福新图景
- ·'Troubling' signs of activity at NK's Punggye
- ·8 Memorable Museums in Los Angeles
- ·Apple reportedly pauses iOS 18 development to focus on bugs
- ·“笋货”上市采购旺!清远西牛麻竹笋迎秋季尝鲜热
- ·Optogenetics: A Virtual Reality System for Controlling Living Cells
- ·Hungary and Slovakia reach Euro 2024
- ·Apple's M3 Max MacBook Pro is as fast as expensive M2 Ultra Mac desktops
- ·雨城区疾控中心提示:科学补碘 防治碘缺乏病
- ·有形有效抓党建促发展惠民生
- ·Best fitness smartwatch deals: Save up to 50% on Fitbit and Google Pixel Watches
- ·A Dozen Accessible Fall Hikes to Delight and Inspire
- ·How to unblock Xnxx for free
- ·省市县三级政协联动,种下一片“广东政协委员林”
- ·Peru accused of xenophobia
- ·Why Korean students prefer math over literature
最新内容
- ·23 Peculiar Places of 2023
- ·'Troubling' signs of activity at NK's Punggye
- ·深化雅涪市场监管一体化协作 助推成渝地区双城经济圈建设
- ·The Ultimate Guide to Wondrous Independent Bookstores
- ·The Analog Embrace: How Some Experiences Are Surviving the Digital Age
- ·Defense Ministry under fire for labeling Dokdo ‘area of territorial dispute’
- ·Best free online courses from Stanford University
- ·Best fitness tracker deal: Save 20% on Fitbit Luxe
- ·[LLG] When compassion meets law: Lawyer defends goats, dogs, other helpless animals
- ·Why South Koreans should have access to Pyongyang's media
推荐内容
热点内容
- ·SCOTUS: The courts implementing Project 2025, without Trump.
- ·YouTube users avoiding ad
- ·Exciting Adventures in West Virginia
- ·Dating apps in Korea overflowing with men, but women use them more: data
- ·Apple iPod: The First 10 Years of the Ubiquitous Media Player
- ·Best Dyson deal: Get the Dyson Purifier Hot+Cool Gen 1 HP10 for 17% off
- ·巩固提升招商引资工作实效 保障全市工业经济稳增长
- ·Verstappen battles through to win LA GP thriller
- ·U.S. Senators call on FTC to investigate the security of drivers' data
- ·“5·15”经侦宣传日 雅安公安公布一批经济犯罪典型案例