Trump could kill the Iran deal by kicking it to Congress.
In a speech at the American Enterprise Institute on Tuesday, Ambassador to the United Nations Nikki Haley gave what might be a preview of how President Trump could finally kill the 2015 nuclear agreement with Iran.
Most of Haley’s speech was familiar: a litany of the Iranian regime’s crimes and malfeasances dating back to 1979 as well as criticism of the “very flawed and very limited agreement” forged between the Obama administration, Iran, five other countries, and the European Union. Haley didn’t dispute the assessments of international inspectors and U.S. intelligence agencies, both of which concluded that Iran is in compliance with the deal, no matter how flawed and limited it may be. These assessments are why, even though Trump has said he wants to dismantle what he has called “the worst deal ever,” he has now twice, reluctantly, certified to Congress that Iran is in compliance. But this certification process is where Haley sees an opening.
The administration is required to make this certification every 90 days in order for Iran to continue to receive relief from sanctions. This requirement is not in the text of the agreement itself, but in an act passed by Congress in 2015, known as the Corker-Cardin law. That law was meant to constrain the Obama administration, but has unintentionally ended up forcing Obama’s successor to take ownership of an agreement he loathes. Now Haley is proposing kicking the ball back to Congress.
AdvertisementIn her speech Tuesday, Haley noted, correctly, that the law states the president must certify not only that Iran is complying with the agreement, but that continuing to provide sanctions relief is “appropriate and proportionate to the specific and verifiable measures taken by Iran with respect to terminating its illicit nuclear program” and “vital to the national security interests of the United States.” Haley argues that Iran’s continued ballistic missile tests demonstrate that it is not terminating its nuclear program, even if they are not “technical violations” of the deal, and that given the support Iran gives to groups like Hezbollah, the sanctions relief provided by the deal is detrimental to U.S. national security interests. So Haley suggests that the law allows Trump to declare Iran noncompliant, even if it is complying. Even better, from the Trump administration’s point of view: Trump wouldn’t really have to take responsibility for the consequences of withdrawing from the deal.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement“If the President chooses not to certify Iranian compliance, that does not mean the United States is withdrawing from the [deal],” Haley said, noting that under the law, Congress would then have “60 days to consider whether to re-impose sanctions on Iran.” The law provides an expedited process for Congress to re-impose sanctions. Haley suggested it should decide whether to do so based on more than just the deal itself.
“During that time, Congress could take the opportunity to debate Iran’s support for terrorism, its past nuclear activity, and its massive human rights violations, all of which are called for in Corker-Cardin,” she said.
As former State Department staffer Ilan Goldenberg points out, this looks an awful lot like how Trump has handled the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or DACA, program this week. Both are controversial Obama initiatives that Trump promised his base he would scrap. And both are things that, if scrapped, could create backlash for the president. So why not just wash his hands of both and let Congress deal?
AdvertisementThe problem in this case is that U.S. allies have been very clear that the agreement was intended to deal with Iran’s nuclear program and have expressed little desire to revisit the issue. Without evidence of a significant violation, this odd Haley argument that Iran is noncompliant with the spirit of the agreement but not the letter of it, is not likely to carry much weight with the other parties. It also would be strategically dumb, because Iran would be freed from its commitments under the deal and the U.S. would have far less leverage than it did before the deal was signed.
Will Trump do it? “While I have discussed it with him, I do not know what decision he will make,” Haley said Tuesday of Trump’s deliberations. “It is his decision to make, and his alone.” However the administration tries to frame it, the responsibility should be his alone as well.
Tweet Share Share Comment-
21 Lost and Lonely CemeteriesMilitary reports 144 more COVIDElizabeth Warren’s 2020 wealth tax plan is constitutional.S. Korea reports additional avian influenza caseSCOTUS: The courts implementing Project 2025, without Trump.Missing bar trivia? There's a coronavirus alternative.案件与两被告相关联 为何只有一被告承担责任Tesla reduces price of nearly every car by $2,000 or more10 Big Misconceptions About Computer HardwareBarcelona dumped out of Europa League
- ·Deceased K
- ·N. Korea's agricultural ministry elevated to state commission amid food shortages
- ·Facebook employees resign over Zuckerberg's treatment of Trump post
- ·金凤山公园二期计划今年国庆假期开放
- ·A Journey Into the Mind of Stephen King
- ·Apple released iOS 13.5, and here's why you should update
- ·如何合理进行家庭理财规划
- ·首批9名“智囊”持证上岗!中国乡村文化振兴专家委员会成立
- ·10 Places to Get to Know Paul Bunyan
- ·Vin Diesel says 'Fast and Furious' saga is racing toward a proper end
- ·首批9名“智囊”持证上岗!中国乡村文化振兴专家委员会成立
- ·NYC taps Twilio to power its massive contact
- ·Where to pre
- ·Dogs and cats are refusing to let their humans work out at home, and it's pretty hilarious
- ·The Angle: Supreme Court forfeiture, Bernie Sanders, movie censorship.
- ·Missing bar trivia? There's a coronavirus alternative.
- ·The Composer Has No Clothes
- ·Educators rally to #TeachTruth as the GOP tries to legislate lessons
- ·S. Korea's daily cases near 7,000, county braces of omicron impact
- ·Talkspace bails on Facebook deal, CEO cites 'violence, racism, and lies'
- ·Against All Odds: How Netflix Made It
- ·Facebook employees walk out over hands
- ·Apple released iOS 13.5, and here's why you should update
- ·Collusion: Mueller’s looking at the Trump campaign’s Russia contacts in different ways.
- ·优化广东优质农产品产销资源对接!“农友圈”又有新动作
- ·Apple now sells refurbished iPhone XR models for up to $120 off
- ·Webb telescope discovers 6 rogue worlds. They didn't form the way you'd expect.
- ·US leaves N. Korea on state sponsors of terrorism list in 2022 report
- ·Military reports 144 more COVID
- ·US says N. Korean actions along DMZ increasing risk of military tensions, miscalculations
- ·[Herald Review] Tori Kelly thrills fans, hints her love for Korean artists
- ·Uber will scan drivers' faces to make sure they're wearing masks
- ·Guardiola refuses to answer reports of Haaland move
- ·Vin Diesel says 'Fast and Furious' saga is racing toward a proper end
- ·Best CPU Deals, AMD vs Intel: Holiday CPU Buying Guide
- ·“养老+金融”助力老有所养