Support for democracy is a partisan issue now.
Wakanda, the fictional and harmonious African country portrayed in the new movie Black Panther, has served as an escape fantasy for many Americans who are dismayed by the bigotry and rank incompetence of Donald Trump’s America. So it’s worth noting one of Wakanda’s most basic but rarely discussed features: It is a kingdom, not a democracy. The film’s hero, T’Challa, is a hereditary ruler, not an elected statesman. Even progressive writers who conjure up a better political world seem to find the idea of making it a democracy a little too far-fetched to be believable. When America dreams of a better future, it turns to that age-old fantasy of a benevolent dictator.
It is with this depressing realization on my mind that I turned to reading what is perhaps the most comprehensive study to date of public perceptions of democracy in the Trump era. Written by Lee Drutman, Larry Diamond, and Joe Goldman, it tries to answer a question first raised in work by Roberto Foa and me: Are citizens now so angry at the failings of their political institutions that they are growing increasingly disenchanted with democracy itself? Is this problem especially pronounced among the young? And what implications does that have for the future stability of our political system? (I present a lot of this work in my new book, The People vs. Democracy.)
Building on a new representative survey, the authors find both some moderately good and thoroughly bad news.
The good news is that Donald Trump seems to be healing some Americans of their long-standing desire for a strongman. As we showed in our original article, the share of respondents who wish for a “strong leader who does not have to bother with parliament and elections” has been rising for the better parts of two decades. And while this increase was marked among all age groups, it was especially prevalent among the young. That trend has now broken. Perhaps in response to the authoritarian leanings of the president, the number of Americans who wish for a strongman leaderhas now receded back to the levels recorded in 1995. And this fall was especially marked among younger voters, who are also likely to hold the most negative views of Donald Trump.
Unfortunately, there are also two important pieces of bad news.
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementThe first of these is that Americans’ attitudes about democracy are rapidly polarizing along partisan lines. Whereas liberals and conservatives held anti-democratic views at roughly equal levels in previous surveys, self-described conservatives are now much more likely to favor a strongman leader than their more liberal peers.
AdvertisementThe report by Diamond, Drutman, and Goldman also suggests that the rise of Donald Trump is one of the big reasons for that. Thirty-two percent of Americans who supported Trump in the primaries favor a strongman leader, for example; among those who voted for Hilary Clinton, Bernie Sanders, John Kasich, Marco Rubio, or Ted Cruz, less than 20 percent did.
Interestingly, the preference for a strong leader was especially pronounced among voters who had voted for Barack Obama in 2012 but switched their allegiance to Donald Trump in 2016. Clearly, the appeal for a strongman was a significant part of the reason why Trump was able to clinch the presidency.
Advertisement AdvertisementThe second piece of bad news is that young people are continuing to grow frustrated with the current system at alarming rates. Indeed, though they are less tempted by a strongman leader than their elders, they are also far more likely to say that democracy may not be preferable to other political systems. While only 15 percent of Americans over the age of 65 held this view, for example, about twice as many people below the age of 30 were open to non-democratic alternatives. (One caveat: Because of survey methodology, data for people below the age of 23 was not available.)
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementWhat emerges, then, is a subtle picture. On the one hand, many Americans may be starting to take warnings about the imminent dangers to democracy to heart. They are more likely now than a few years ago to recognize the danger posed by a strongman leader, and seem to be recommitting to the importance of living in a democracy as a result.
On the other hand, a commitment to the basic rules, norms, and institutions of our democratic system had once been a nonpartisan value; now, it is increasingly becoming a distinguishing characteristic of Trump’s opponents. Meanwhile, a lot of young people reject Trump out of hand—but are also growing so frustrated with the evident failings of democracy that they are more and more open to authoritarian alternatives.
Advertisement Advertisement AdvertisementIt is tempting to look at young Americans’ rejection of Donald Trump and conclude that the kids are all right. But a look at both the data in this important survey, and the recent election results across Europe, should disabuse us of that notion. Last year, French youngsters voted for both the far-left Jean-Luc Mélenchon and the far-right Marine Le Pen in record numbers. Last week, Italian youngsters voted for both the ideologically amorphous Five Star Movement and the far-right League in even greater numbers.
In short, young Americans’ rejection of the particular populist who currently holds the office of president is pretty thorough. But their rejection of populism, or indeed their hankering for a political system that dispenses with all the evident frustrations and inefficiencies of liberal democracy, is not.
Tweet Share Share Comment-
Amazon Android Days sale 2024: Save on unlocked phones, tablets, and moreYouTube killed Discord's most popular music bot, RhythmAmazon's newest kid“茶院士”来雅盛赞名山县是“名副其实的中国茶乡”The OLED Burn6 new Prince songs will be released on FridayGoogle Play update makes it easy to delete unusued Android appsSamsung Galaxy S8 shows amazing resilience to abuse in new videoA Journey Into the Mind of Stephen KingElon Musk says sending profane email 'one of the dumbest things I've ever done'
- ·Swifties for Kamala raises over $100,000 in donations for Harris campaign
- ·家居家电市场 售后服务决定消费者购买选向
- ·广东医疗援疆纪实:第1000名喀什乡亲踏上“粤新光明之路”
- ·第二十二届广东种业大会佛山分会场12月5日启幕(创意农业篇)
- ·Best CPU Deals, AMD vs Intel: Holiday CPU Buying Guide
- ·S. Korea keeps close tabs on N. Korea's possible provocations
- ·端午节 吃了粽子还剩下啥?
- ·This watchOS 8 feature is a big improvement for fitness apps
- ·CrowdStrike outage is still causing hundreds of flight cancellations daily
- ·Ig Nobel Prize winners include scientists who cleared blocked noses with sex
- ·NK fires ballistic missile ahead of US
- ·Why the renovated Apple Fifth Avenue store isn't just another store
- ·From Prairie Grasslands to Man
- ·高考结束 放下包袱 我们只要快乐
- ·品樱桃 观新湖 看革命老区新发展
- ·切实加强青衣江水资源保护 还青衣江一江清水
- ·[From the Scene] How ‘world’s first oil town’ is wrestling to become ‘green'
- ·Marvel reveals the full track list for the 'Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2' soundtrack
- ·Portugal cuts diplomatic ties with North Korea
- ·依法规范农业技术推广体系建设
- ·Police bust crypto scammer who received plastic surgery to evade arrest
- ·Civil servants to leave work at 4 p.m. once a month
- ·承古人遗风 祭诗人屈原
- ·石棉工商:干部职工参观恢复重建陈列馆
- ·Nvidia GeForce Now Ultimate vs. New Graphics Card
- ·Sandia Labs completes nuclear triathlon to test spent fuel safety
- ·How to Backup Your Gmail Account
- ·What can — or should — we learn from porn?
- ·Lyft's new look lays out all its travel options on one app screen
- ·石棉工商:干部职工参观恢复重建陈列馆
- ·Aricell CEO arrested in first case under industrial accidents law
- ·韶关翁源:“中国兰花第一县”绽放高质量发展之花
- ·荥经工商:启动民主评议政风行风工作
- ·US sanctions 7 North Koreans, 3 entities over human rights abuses
- ·Prime exclusive deal: $50 off Govee floor lamp
- ·荥经工商:启动民主评议政风行风工作