What are deepfakes? A guide to the internet's new face
Where there's innovation, there's masturbation — at least in one dark corner of the internet, where nearly 80,000 people have gathered to share fabricated videos of celebrity women having sex and Nicolas Cage uncovering the Ark of the Covenant.
These are "deepfakes," a new kind of video featuring realistic face-swaps. In short, a computer program finds common ground between two faces and stitches one over the other. If the source footage is good enough, the transformation is nearly seamless.
The technology is relatively easy to use, which has created an enthusiast community on Reddit, where users compare notes and swap their latest work: "Emma Watson sex tape demo ;-)," "Lela Star x Kim Kardashian," and "Giving Putin the Trump face" among them.
This scene from "Raiders of the Lost Ark" originally starred Harrison Ford, not Nicolas Cage, though an untrained eye may not know the difference.Credit: Nick Cage DeepFakes/YoiuTubeMotherboard did foundational reporting on deepfakes in December and continues to cover the trend, with despairingly predictable news last week that people are using the technology to create porn starring friends and classmates. But legal and computer science experts told Mashable that the technology's grimier applications shouldn't overshadow its potential for good, even if it's difficult to see the upside when non-consenting stars are being jammed into hardcore sex scenes with hundreds of thousands of views on Pornhub and Reddit.
The latter company didn't respond to requests for comment over the course of a week, but Pornhub said it will remove deepfakes from its platform.
"Users have started to flag content like this, and we are taking it down as soon as we encounter the flags," Corey Price, PornHub's vice president, said. "We encourage anyone who encounters this issue to visit our content removal page so they can officially make a request."
Still, to be very clear: All of this should freak you out.
Gal Gadot's face, digitally stitched into a porn clipCredit: redditAbove, we see Gal Gadot's face superimposed onto a porn actress, moments before she pulls her shirt off and gets felt up. Consent didn't factor into the equation for the Redditor who made this clip, and a casual observer wouldn't know the video is fake if they received the file from a friend via text message or email, because the transformation is so well done.
The issue is pretty simple: A person who has not consented to a sexual situation should not be put into that situation, whether in physical or virtual life. But the genie is out of the bottle, and it's staying there. "Gal Gadot" remains one of the top terms associated with deepfake searches on Google, as the company's own Trends data shows:
This underscores the urgency of the problem, even if it's an emerging one. Content published to the internet can be hard to erase, particularly when there's a group of people invested in duplicating and spreading it. People could stop creating new deepfakes tomorrow, but Gal Gadot's clips could live on indefinitely.
Want help? It's murky
There's not much legal recourse for those who fall victim to this new technology, according to Jonathan Masur, a professor who specializes in patent and technology law at the University of Chicago Law School. That's true even for private citizens.
"There's the copyright claim, if you took the [footage] yourself. There's the defamation claim if someone tries to say that it's actually you. And if you're a celebrity, there's a right to publicity claim if someone is trying to make money off of it," Masur explained. "But each of those is just a narrow slice of what's going on here that won't cover the vast majority of situations."
Many of the of these videos acknowledge they're fake, which undermines a defamation argument.
"[You] could try to make a case it represents a form of defamation if you're attacking the reputation of someone, but that's also pretty hard to do because, by definition, you're not alleging you're posting a pornographic picture of that individual," he said.
And, no, recent efforts to ban revenge pornography, led by Mary Ann Franks and Danielle Citron, wouldn't be applied in these cases, because those laws pertain to the release of private images or video of an individual.
"There's no pornographic picture of the actual individual being released," Masur said. "It's just the individual's face on someone else's body."
Deepfakes also have political ramifications, though no one would fall for this fusion of Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton.Credit: thegoncas2/youtubeThere aren't any laws against this practice yet, nor have they been introduced. Tackling deepfakes via new legislation would be tricky, as doing so would bump against the First Amendment.
"From a civil liberties perspective, I am... concerned that the response to this innovation will be censorial and end up punishing and discouraging protected speech," David Greene, the civil liberties director at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a nonprofit focused on digital free speech, said.
"It would be a bad idea, and likely unconstitutional, for example, to criminalize the technology," he added.
The unexpected upside
Greene's concerns may not be unfounded. Though deepfakes are now synonymous with porn, the basic concept behind the technology is facial recognition, which theoretically has a lot of upside to be explored.
You may already be familiar with basic, live facial recognition from apps like Snapchat. The technology is programmed to map faces according to "landmark" points. These are features like the corners of your eyes and mouth, your nostrils, and the contour of your jawline.
Snapchat is pretty good at understanding your face and applying transformative effects, which augment your features:
One of the authors, as a chipmunk.Credit: SnapchatBut its face-swapping feature leaves something to be desired:
Credit: snapchatPart of that has to do with Snapchat working in real-time — it's trading speed for accuracy.
Deepfakes work differently. The "FakeApp" program uses artificial intelligence to complete three major steps: alignment, training, and merging. Instead of placing one face over another in real-time, the FakeApp uses hundreds of still-frame images pulled from video footage. It digs through all of those images, identifies faces, and analyzes how they're lit, what expressions they're making, and so on. Once the program understands the faces it's working with, it can use all of its "knowledge" to stitch one over the other.
Though it's been put to a gross purpose, deepfakes' seamlessness could be an encouraging sign, depending on your perspective. With enough development, real-time face swaps could achieve similar quality to deepfakes, which may have therapeutic uses, according to Dr. Louis-Philippe Morency, director of the MultiComp Lab at Carnegie Mellon University.
"This technology has very important applications apart from entertainment," he said.
One moonshot example: Dr. Morency said soldiers suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder could eventually video-conference with doctors using similar technology. An individual could face-swap with a generic model without sacrificing the ability to convey his or her emotions. In theory, this would encourage people to get treatment who might otherwise be deterred by a perceived stigma, and the quality of their treatment wouldn't suffer due to a doctor being unable to read their facial cues.
Another one of Dr. Morency's possibilities — and its own can of worms — would be to use models in video interviews to remove gender or racial bias when hiring. But for any of this to happen, researchers need more data, and open-source, accessible programs like FakeApp can help create that data.
"The way to move forward with AI research is to share the code, and share the data. This is an enabler for AI research," Dr. Morency said.
It somehow gets worse
As with many emerging technologies, the scariest part may be unseen. When Facebook first rolled out on college campuses, few would have anticipated its transformation into a multimedia Goliath that potentially destabilized American democracy as we knew it — but here we are.
Like the "fake news" that has exhausted so many of us on Facebook, deepfakes represent yet another capacity for the internet to breach our shared reality. If every video clip could potentially be fake, why believe anything is real?
And so, expect the response from your unborn grandchild: "Raiders of the Lost Ark? You mean the one with Nicolas Cage?"
Featured Video For You
Why Lena Headey is campaigning to support refugee families in Europe
-
NYT Strands hints, answers for August 29小米手机保护套锁定怎么用(小米2手机的保护锁定怎么解)小米手机2上市时间(小米2手机何时发布发布时如何抢先购买)债券基金有哪些影响(债券基金有哪些风险)Which is Faster for Gaming, Windows 10 or Windows 11?小米手机2上市时间(小米2手机何时发布发布时如何抢先购买)信用卡停息挂账申请办法(信用卡停息挂账会影响征信吗)城乡医保在网上怎么缴费(城乡医保网上如何缴费)22 Unusual Things You Can Find in the Desert信用卡全额还款后还有下一期吗(信用卡全额还款后还有利息吗)
- ·Flying spaghetti monster and unworldly life filmed in deep sea footage
- ·小米手机保护套锁定怎么用(小米2手机的保护锁定怎么解)
- ·每个人最多可以开几个股票账户(每个人最多可以开几个股票账户)
- ·诺基亚6220c和诺基亚5320 XpressMusic哪个好?
- ·Tesla reveals Cybertruck has sold more than DeLorean
- ·诺基亚n73和5320哪个好(诺基亚N73音乐版和5320哪个好)
- ·诺基亚5230xm怎么样(诺基亚5310XM和5320XM买哪个好)
- ·小米手机哪个型号最好(小米手机)
- ·AirPods Pro 3 and AirPods 4 may get revealed at the Apple September event
- ·转增股票是利好吗(转增股票对股价有什么影响)
- ·小米手机有全国免流量功能吗(小米手机有全国保修吗)
- ·nokia5320港行原装配件包有哪些?有光驱和耳机线控制吗?
- ·NASA's new plan keeps Starliner astronauts in space until 2025
- ·借呗和网商贷有什么区别哪个划算(借呗和网商贷有什么区别)
- ·场内基金卖出要收印花税吗(场内基金可以随时卖出吗)
- ·期房能抵押贷款吗(期房能做抵押贷款吗)
- ·Carbon neutrality law violates basic rights: Constitutional Court
- ·诺基亚5630xm和5320(诺基亚5320XM和诺基亚N78哪个好)
- ·基金上午卖和下午卖有区别吗(基金上午卖和下午卖有区别吗)
- ·基金会不会像股票一样被套牢(基金会不会像股票一样有退市)
- ·尝“鲜”盛宴,等你来探!2024年清远西牛麻竹笋尝鲜季即将启幕
- ·车保险买哪几种最合适并讲解(车保险买哪几种就够了)
- ·每个人最多可以开几个股票账户(每个人最多可以开几个股票账户)
- ·想买手机诺基亚5320 XpressMusic诺基亚6303c诺基亚6220c?
- ·24 Museums Dedicated to Black History
- ·支付宝骑士卡有多少额度(支付宝骑士卡有什么用)
- ·让法治建设成效更加可感可及
- ·如何区分诺基亚5320 XpressMusic和正品?
- ·诺基亚5230和5320(诺基亚5320和LG KF350哪个好)
- ·淘宝商家手机如何开通花呗收款(淘宝商家怎么开通花呗收款)
- ·[From the Scene] How ‘world’s first oil town’ is wrestling to become ‘green'
- ·诺基亚5320 XpressMusic可以为您的电脑充电并使用数据线连接电脑
- ·nokia5320港行原装配件包有哪些?有光驱和耳机线控制吗?
- ·诺基亚5230xm怎么样(诺基亚5320XM好处在哪里)
- ·[Online Predators] Deepfake pornography haunts S. Korea
- ·诺基亚5320XM和诺基亚5320XpressMusic有什么区别?拜托了