Massive study finds nearly no increase to diversity in popular films
It's tempting to believe that the recent groundswell in talk about Hollywood's diversity problem would result in actual improvement. But the numbers — at least so far — paint a sobering story.
A new comprehensive study from USC's Annenberg Inclusion Initiative found that the top 100 grossing films from 2007 to 2017 (1,100 total) show minimal to no change over the stated 11 years of the study. Both on- and off-screen, exclusion of marginalized races, ethnicities, sexual orientations, and genders, as well as people with disabilities, remains as high as ever.
SEE ALSO:New report finds abysmal diversity numbers among film directors in 2017Zeroing in on 2017 alone — when the rhetoric around inclusion started reaching its recent peak — shows that talk is cheap. Change requires action. We should take this as a reminder that a shift in rhetoric does not necessarily equal a shift in reality. Hard numbers will help keep Hollywood accountable for its promises to work toward a more inclusive future.
"As the reverberations of the #MeToo and #TimesUp movements continue to resonate in the entertainment industry and beyond, this investigation marks how far we still have to go," wrote researcher Dr. Stacy L. Smith. "Workplace safety goes hand in hand with workplace equity."
When examining on-screen representation in 2017, the researchers looked at more than 4,454 speaking characters.
A full 68.2% of these characters were male, vs. 31.8% female. That's only a 1.9 percentage improvement from 2007. The number of female protagonists has basically remained stagnant since 2015, actually decreasing in 2017 from 2016's 34% down to 33%.
Credit: USC ANNENBERG/Dr. Stacy L. Smith, Marc Choueiti, Dr. Katherine Pieper, Ariana Case, & Angel ChoiUnsurprisingly, women of color show the most dismal percentage of inclusion, with only four (FOUR!) of the top 100 films in 2017 featuring them as leads or co-leads. It's also notable that these few women of color were all of mixed race and ethnicity.
Overall, the invisibility of white, cis, heterosexual, able-bodied women pales in comparison to that of all other marginalized identities.
As far as speaking characters in 2017 went, 70.7% were white. That means only 12.1% were black, 4.8% Asian, 6.2% Hispanic/Latino, 1.7% Middle Eastern, and less than 1% American Indian/Alaskan Native and Native Hawaiian, while 3.9% were categorized as mixed race or other.
As if that wasn't bleak enough, little progress has been made in the area of diverse sexuality. We've pointed out before that despite creators and actors being happy to retroactively tout a character's non-heteronormativity off-screen, on-screen visibility is what really matters.
Out of 4,403 characters in 2017, only 0.7% were lesbian, gay, or bisexual, with a much higher percentage of gay representation (51.6%) than lesbian (29%) or bisexual (19.4%) representation combined. Again, those numbers have basically remained stagnant since 2014. And since 2014, only a single transgender character appeared, back in 2015.
Credit: USC ANNENBERG/DR. STACY L. SMITH, MARC CHOUEITI, DR. KATHERINE PIEPER, ARIANA CASE, & ANGEL CHOIBy far, the most underrepresented group of all were people with disabilities. They made up 2.5% of the characters in the most popular films of 2017. In terms of protagonists, 14% of the films included leads with disabilities. In the breakdown of types of disability represented, mental disability remains the most stigmatized category at 26.8%. Physical disability accounted for 61.6% of representation, and communicative disabilities came in at 30.4%. These numbers were also roughly the same over the past several years.
But the real kicker are the diversity numbers behindthe camera. Spoiler alert: Terrible on-screen representation does indeed appear to flow from those who are in charge of casting.
Credit: USC ANNENBERG/DR. STACY L. SMITH, MARC CHOUEITI, DR. KATHERINE PIEPER, ARIANA CASE, & ANGEL CHOIOf the 1,584 of directors, writers, and producers in 2017, 81.7% were male and 18.2% were female — only 7.3% were women directors. In fact, across all 11 years of the study, only 43 women had the opportunity to helm top-grossing films. However, when women dodirect, their casts are much more equal as far as gender, with 43% of speaking characters being women and girls.
Once again, though, that number is a vast improvement compared to the numbers for directors of color.
Out of the 109 directors of top-grossing films in 2017, 5.5% were black, and only one was a woman (hi, Ava). While that percentage has remained basically the same over the past 11 years, only four black women helmed any of those movies. As with women directors, black representation on-screen increases to 41.8% with a black director.
Asian-American directors were nearly nonexistent, with only four helming top movies in 2017. Only three Asian-American women directed movies over the time spanned by the study.
Credit: USC ANNENBERG/DR. STACY L. SMITH, MARC CHOUEITI, DR. KATHERINE PIEPER, ARIANA CASE, & ANGEL CHOICredit: USC ANNENBERG/DR. STACY L. SMITH, MARC CHOUEITI, DR. KATHERINE PIEPER, ARIANA CASE, & ANGEL CHOIWhat all of this does is give inarguable evidence supporting what we've heard countless marginalized people working in the industry say before: Exclusion is endemic to popular films.
Dr. Stacy L. Smith suggests multiple solutions to fixing these numbers. Chief among them are inclusion riders (which Frances McDormand mentioned in her acceptance speech for best actress at the 2017 Oscars), target goals, revamping diversity policies, and demanding #5050by2020 for female representation in popular films.
SEE ALSO:How to be part of the solution to sexual harassment problems in HollywoodThe full document offers a lot more nuance in terms of trends in how marginalized characters are portrayed, and how diversity behind the camera influences on-screen portrayal. So be sure to check it out for yourself here.
We have yet to see whether 2018 will reflect more substantive change. Working to make sure it does isn't just the right thing to do morally. It's the right thing for the health of the industry.
"Addressing the lack of inclusivity in cinema is an essential part of building a future in which talented individuals can safely create, inspire, and entertain audiences who are finally able to see their own challenges and triumphs on screen," Dr. Smith concluded.
Featured Video For You
The first queen of 'Medieval Times' is ushering in a new era of representation
TopicsActivismDiversitySocial Good
-
雅安公安接连破获两起汉源湖非法捕捞案'Watch Dogs: Legion' review: Freeing London from technofascism预见2024丨中国预制菜行业六大趋势预测Unification minister reiterates resolve to revive peace efforts with N. KoreaBy a technicality, August's full moon is blue. Here's why.Facebook bug secretly turns on iPhone camera冠军最高2748公斤/亩 !2023年荔枝龙眼园高产竞赛结果揭晓水稻产业园签约落地,郁南县平台镇、三水区大塘镇两地村企共建结出硕果Yoon touts pension reform drive amid stagnant popularity rating'Watch Dogs: Legion' review: Freeing London from technofascism
- ·NYT Strands hints, answers for August 29
- ·How returnships can help during a female
- ·The dark side of college
- ·Uber CEO downplays murder of Jamal Khashoggi as 'mistake,' then backtracks
- ·NYT Strands hints, answers for August 29
- ·Samsung's new Galaxy Book laptops have wireless charging touchpads
- ·I used to wash my face with dish soap. Here's my attempt at a skincare routine.
- ·Tinder's Ghosting Graveyard helps you craft a text to the person you ghosted
- ·Weather update for second Pak vs Ban second Test match day one
- ·Military reports 9 additional COVID
- ·iFixit teardown confirms the iPhone 12 and 12 Pro are mostly identical
- ·Google revealed a security flaw on Halloween, so maybe update Chrome now
- ·Tesla reveals Cybertruck has sold more than DeLorean
- ·Segway goes off road with its new electric dirt bike
- ·Notion is the underrated productivity app that may change your work life
- ·NK says S. Korea, US will pay 'terrible price' if they use force
- ·Coach jailed for sexual exploitation of underage athlete
- ·N. Korea builds ice cream factory on Kim Jong
- ·Trump vows to “get rid” of “lingering stench” at Justice Department and FBI.
- ·Yes, you can teach your cat to fetch
- ·[From the Scene] How ‘world’s first oil town’ is wrestling to become ‘green'
- ·水稻产业园签约落地,郁南县平台镇、三水区大塘镇两地村企共建结出硕果
- ·Sad internet boy Elon Musk decides to log off. Again.
- ·Anisimova stuns Osaka to set up Barty showdown
- ·If aliens harnessed solar power, could we detect them? NASA investigated.
- ·这波团圆饭的松弛感,高要拿捏住了!
- ·Best Labor Day headphones deals: Apple, Bose, Beats, and more on sale
- ·YouTube rolls out big changes to its desktop homepage
- ·6 quirky gifts to help you break your smartphone addiction
- ·Instagram tests new feature that looks suspiciously like TikTok
- ·16 of the Most Epic Sandwiches Around the Planet
- ·Twitter's new ad policy prompts politicians to call out Facebook
- ·Signal could make NBA's tampering problem even harder to solve
- ·89 cities, counties, wards designated as depopulation areas
- ·How much will PCB's Champions Cup mentors be paid?
- ·NK fires 1 short