Twitter/X confirms Nazi content was shown alongside Apple ads. So why is it suing?
Twitter/X is suing media watchdog group Media Matters over its Nov. 16 report that the social media platform was displaying major companies' ads alongside Nazi content. The report came just one day after Twitter/X owner Elon Musk endorsed an anti-Semitic conspiracy, prompting huge advertisers such as Apple and Disney to flee.
Filed in Texas on Monday, Twitter/X's lawsuit accuses Media Matters of "manufacturing" the screenshots in its report that show advertisers' posts alongside white nationalist content. According to Twitter/X, this was done as a deliberate, malicious attack to "drive advertisers from the platform and destroy X Corp."
SEE ALSO:X advertisers that have reportedly pulled ads recently: See the list, including Disney and Apple."The split second court opens on Monday, X Corp will be filing a thermonuclear lawsuit against Media Matters and ALL those who colluded in this fraudulent attack on our company," Musk posted on Twitter/X over the weekend.
Unfortunately for Musk, the "thermonuclear" nature of its lawsuit is highly debatable.
What is the Twitter/X vs Media Matter lawsuit about?
Twitter/X doesn't claim that the screenshots in Media Matters' recent report were fake or created via image editing software. In fact, it validates them as real, confirming that Media Matters did indeed see Apple, Bravo, Oracle, Xfinity, and IBM advertisements next to posts celebrating Nazism on Twitter/X.
Instead, the lawsuit alleges that Media Matters was able to see advertisers' content next to Nazi content by using profiles which had been active for over 30 days, "bypassing X's ad filter for new users," and only following accounts from either prominent advertisers or "those known to produce extreme fringe content." The social media platform also claimed that Media Matters excessively scrolled and refreshed its feed, resulting in it viewing more ads per hour than most users.
Twitter/X is seeking damages as well as the removal of Media Matters' report, which will no doubt prompt many more people to read it.
Not quite 'thermonuclear'
The lawsuit attempts to characterise Media Matter's use of Twitter/X as a manipulation of the platform's algorithm, and claims that its results were "inorganic" and "rare." However, this doesn't negate the fact that advertisers and Nazi content were shown side by side. It also isn't impossible that an established user might follow both white supremacist and big brand accounts.
Other Twitter/X users have since reported being served ads when searching for anti-Semitic phrases, including posts from the German government, an Israeli oil and gas company, New Jersey Tourism, and The Athletic.
Interestingly, Twitter/X's claim that Media Matters followed accounts "known to produce extreme fringe content" further indicates that the platform has allowed such profiles to continue posting white supremacist content long enough to gain notoriety. As of writing, half of the accounts Media Matters screenshotted posting Nazi content still remain active.
Tweet may have been deleted
Amidst all this, Twitter/X CEO Linda Yaccarino confirmed that the platform did show big advertisers' posts next to white supremacist content, but attempted to play it down by stating that nearly nobody saw it.
"Not a single authentic user on X saw IBM’s, Comcast’s, or Oracle’s ads next to the content in Media Matters’ article," Yaccarino posted on Monday. "Only 2 users saw Apple’s ad next to the content, at least one of which was Media Matters."
Related Stories
- Apple pauses ads on X / Twitter after Elon Musk endorses antisemitic conspiracy
- IBM pulls ads from X/Twitter as Elon Musk promotes anti-Semitic conspiracy
- X / Twitter lets Israel-Gaza hate speech spread, new study finds — and these users are the culprits
- Right-wing influencers pledge to bail out Elon Musk after Apple, Disney, others suspend advertising on X
- One year after Musk acquired Twitter: Traffic, revenue down across the board
Even so, the objections are likely less about how many people saw it, and more about it being a possibility in the first place.
Twitter/X is searching for a scapegoat
Combined with Musk's recent comments supporting a conspiracy theory that Jewish people are pushing hatred against white people, it isn't hard to see why advertisers such as IBM, Warner Bros. Discovery, and Paramount Global are suspending their ads on Twitter/X.
"This is a frivolous lawsuit meant to bully X’s critics into silence," Media Matters' president Angelo Carusone wrote on Twitter/X. "Media Matters stands behind its reporting and looks forward to winning in court."
Tweet may have been deleted
This isn't the first time brands halted their advertising on Twitter/X due to Nazi content. In August, pharmaceutical giant Gilead and NCTA — The Internet & Television Association both stopped advertising on Twitter/X after a previous Media Matters report found ads displayed on white supremacist content. Alongside Gilead, the report specifically named several other companies such as Adobe, Amazon, Fortune, MLB, Samsung, and Sports Illustrated.
However, it seems the loss of giants like Apple and Disney has been enough for Twitter/X to try making Media Matters a scapegoat — and hope the courts simply overlook its advertiser-unfriendly policies and Musk's own statements.
TopicsTwitterElon Musk
-
Newborns hit new low, but births to those unmarried reach record high: data青岛海关破获走私出口3000余吨膨胀石墨案潮南驻雷岭镇帮扶工作队联合专家开展培训,助荔枝产业高质量发展我市公务员全员纳入工伤保险保障体系10 Big Misconceptions About Computer Hardware碧桂园、海尔、青啤、青饮跨界大联合 417重塑你的未来健康家强化监督 筑牢责任“防火墙”市作协第四次会员代表大会召开Carbon neutrality law violates basic rights: Constitutional Court82岁老人走进山东老字号百年栈桥白酒公司寻找“老味道”
下一篇:A Global Tour of Bakeries With Fascinating Histories
- ·A Journey Into the Mind of Stephen King
- ·做好健康风险防范 新华保险赔付投保人重疾保险16万元
- ·丹青绘山水 “画”说家园美
- ·12强出炉!清远市清城区农产品区域公用品牌创意设计评选活动结果公示
- ·Project 2025 Comstock Act: Trump’s new abortion comment exposed.
- ·青岛技能人才专场网络招聘 369家企业供岗5600个
- ·助力战“疫” 农行青岛分行组织全行员工开展无偿献血公益活动
- ·海医会政策解读下基层会议在雅安召开
- ·New image shows the North Star is changing. And it has spots.
- ·闈掑矝娓?019骞村害涓氱哗锛氳惀鏀跺悓姣斿3.6%
- ·应对挑战抢抓机遇 再造一个产业芦山
- ·蔡汝健:打造养猪服务平台,共建开放共享新生态
- ·Newborns hit new low, but births to those unmarried reach record high: data
- ·青岛海关破获走私出口3000余吨膨胀石墨案
- ·民族歌舞、援疆成果、名优疆品……这个周末的海心沙“疆味”十足!
- ·弘扬非遗文化,《南农》助力土特产进大湾区
- ·Naver, Kakao strive to combat deepfake porn spreading online
- ·青岛西海岸新区中德生态园小学开展家校“接力式”发课本行动
- ·董家口港区原油码头二期工程复工建设
- ·重达30斤,湛江金鲳海捕节头鱼拍出188888元!
- ·25 Years Later: A Brief Analysis of GPU Processing Efficiency
- ·创联工场12周年:用时间镌刻联合办公品牌价值
- ·“盘活”干旱村资源 当好技术指导员
- ·市市场监督管理局推进市场监管系统常态化扫黑除恶专项斗争工作
- ·Foreign, multicultural students rise amid declining school population
- ·连州菜心进社区,万份菜心免费送
- ·Best smart home deal: The Amazon Smart Thermostat is just $63.99
- ·弘扬非遗文化,《南农》助力土特产进大湾区
- ·民族歌舞、援疆成果、名优疆品……这个周末的海心沙“疆味”十足!
- ·加强疫情防控 确保派件安全及时
- ·CPUs Don't Matter For 4K Gaming... Wrong!
- ·市市场监督管理局推进市场监管系统常态化扫黑除恶专项斗争工作
- ·烹制美食盛宴!云浮云城区“粤菜师傅”厨艺竞赛在前锋镇举办
- ·网购泔水、方便面碎等“平替”饲料,广东、广西多地养殖户遭诈骗
- ·Alcaraz, Sinner survive US Open wobbles
- ·发挥特检技术优势 保障重大工程项目建设