Is Japan really security threat to Korea?
时间:2024-09-22 19:46:25 来源:American news
Japan’s passage last week of the controversial legislation to expand its security role is stirring public concerns here, with Seoul officials scurrying to allay them by repeating that Tokyo cannot use its forces at will in a Korean emergency.
Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe attends a parliamentary session. (Yonhap)
Amid the growing angst over Japan loosening its postwar stricture on the use of force, the issue of whether the country is really a potential security threat to Korea, as it was in the early 20th century, has been the subject of public debate.
Some experts say that with the export-driven economy sticking to international norms and rules, it can hardly become a security threat, and that Japan expanding its role in support of the U.S. military would be helpful to cope with contingencies on the peninsula.
Others, however, talk of the possibility that Japan could revert to the militarism of its past, particularly when nationalist policymakers are leading state affairs, and refuse to fully atone for their country’s wartime misdeeds.
With the divergent views, observers say Japan’s pursuit of what it calls a “normal” state with a full-fledged military, which goes beyond the hitherto exclusively defensive security role, will be a double-edged sword.
“Japan’s security policy is obviously a double-edged sword for South Korea as it would be helpful in handling North Korea-related security contingencies, and it would also fan public fears about potential security challenges,” said Park Hwee-rhak, political science professor at Kookmin University.
“What is important for now is that instead of continuing to talk about the double-edged sword, Korea should think more deeply about how it can actually use the sword for its own benefit.”
Public worries over Japan’s new security legislation have reaffirmed that many Koreans still perceive Japan as a possible security threat, a reason why Seoul officials have repeatedly called on Tokyo to carry out its defense policy in a “transparent” manner that promotes regional peace.
Seoul’s Defense Minister Han Min-koo reiterated Monday that without Seoul’s request or consent, Tokyo cannot send its forces to the peninsula, even if the U.S. requests the deployment of Japanese forces here.
“The wartime operational control is exercised in accordance with the guidelines from leaders of both South Korea and the U.S. Thus, if our president rejects (the U.S. request for Japan’s troop dispatch to Korea), the troops cannot enter South Korea,” he said during a parliamentary session.
Analysts say that Japan’s security legislation should be more thoroughly examined to identify aspects that would help South Korea’s security in a crisis, although security concerns seem inevitable, with many Koreans still harboring animosity toward Japan that colonized Korea from 1910-45.
“If you check the 11 security laws in detail, there are many elements to strengthen the U.S.-Japan security cooperation to deter North Korea’s military provocations,” said Park Young-june, political science professor at Korea National Defense University.
“The laws ensure stepped-up security cooperation on the part of Japan … for instance, Japan’s enhanced rear-area support in case of contingencies involving the Korean Peninsula. The strengthened alliance between the U.S. and Japan, in fact, would help the Korea-U.S. security collaboration in many aspects,” he added.
Lee Won-deog, a professor of international politics at Kookmin University, noted that given Japan’s current economic status and aged population, it is highly unlikely for Japan to adopt any militaristic external policy as it did during World War II.
“The 20th-century Japan is different from the current 21st-century Japan, although we still have suspicions as to its militaristic past,” he said.
“Realistically speaking, Japan does not have the strong economic foundation now to pursue any imperialist policy. Its population is old and shrinking, and it is not in a position to jack up its defense spending to push for any unilateral military policy. That is unthinkable for now.”
To prevent a set of worst-case scenarios, including Japan unilaterally intervening in peninsular affairs on the grounds that they could affect its own security, experts say that Seoul needs to strengthen dialogue channels with Tokyo and should seek to establish multilateral security cooperation mechanisms.
Regional cooperation mechanisms would help prevent Japan from taking destabilizing military steps and lead the archipelago state to remain committed to its stated goal of making a “proactive” contribution to global peace.
“While looking at Japan’s security policy, South Korea needs to take into consideration all possibilities and scenarios. It should not be naive and should remain cool-headed,” said Nam Ki-jeong, a professor at the Institute for Japanese Studies at Seoul National University.
“What it can do is to work up diplomacy to lead Japan to move in the right direction within the multilateral security cooperation mechanism. The U.S., China and Russia can also get involved in the mechanism to promote the overall regional peace.”By Song Sang-ho (sshluck@heraldcorp.com)
Amid the growing angst over Japan loosening its postwar stricture on the use of force, the issue of whether the country is really a potential security threat to Korea, as it was in the early 20th century, has been the subject of public debate.
Some experts say that with the export-driven economy sticking to international norms and rules, it can hardly become a security threat, and that Japan expanding its role in support of the U.S. military would be helpful to cope with contingencies on the peninsula.
Others, however, talk of the possibility that Japan could revert to the militarism of its past, particularly when nationalist policymakers are leading state affairs, and refuse to fully atone for their country’s wartime misdeeds.
With the divergent views, observers say Japan’s pursuit of what it calls a “normal” state with a full-fledged military, which goes beyond the hitherto exclusively defensive security role, will be a double-edged sword.
“Japan’s security policy is obviously a double-edged sword for South Korea as it would be helpful in handling North Korea-related security contingencies, and it would also fan public fears about potential security challenges,” said Park Hwee-rhak, political science professor at Kookmin University.
“What is important for now is that instead of continuing to talk about the double-edged sword, Korea should think more deeply about how it can actually use the sword for its own benefit.”
Public worries over Japan’s new security legislation have reaffirmed that many Koreans still perceive Japan as a possible security threat, a reason why Seoul officials have repeatedly called on Tokyo to carry out its defense policy in a “transparent” manner that promotes regional peace.
Seoul’s Defense Minister Han Min-koo reiterated Monday that without Seoul’s request or consent, Tokyo cannot send its forces to the peninsula, even if the U.S. requests the deployment of Japanese forces here.
“The wartime operational control is exercised in accordance with the guidelines from leaders of both South Korea and the U.S. Thus, if our president rejects (the U.S. request for Japan’s troop dispatch to Korea), the troops cannot enter South Korea,” he said during a parliamentary session.
Analysts say that Japan’s security legislation should be more thoroughly examined to identify aspects that would help South Korea’s security in a crisis, although security concerns seem inevitable, with many Koreans still harboring animosity toward Japan that colonized Korea from 1910-45.
“If you check the 11 security laws in detail, there are many elements to strengthen the U.S.-Japan security cooperation to deter North Korea’s military provocations,” said Park Young-june, political science professor at Korea National Defense University.
“The laws ensure stepped-up security cooperation on the part of Japan … for instance, Japan’s enhanced rear-area support in case of contingencies involving the Korean Peninsula. The strengthened alliance between the U.S. and Japan, in fact, would help the Korea-U.S. security collaboration in many aspects,” he added.
Lee Won-deog, a professor of international politics at Kookmin University, noted that given Japan’s current economic status and aged population, it is highly unlikely for Japan to adopt any militaristic external policy as it did during World War II.
“The 20th-century Japan is different from the current 21st-century Japan, although we still have suspicions as to its militaristic past,” he said.
“Realistically speaking, Japan does not have the strong economic foundation now to pursue any imperialist policy. Its population is old and shrinking, and it is not in a position to jack up its defense spending to push for any unilateral military policy. That is unthinkable for now.”
To prevent a set of worst-case scenarios, including Japan unilaterally intervening in peninsular affairs on the grounds that they could affect its own security, experts say that Seoul needs to strengthen dialogue channels with Tokyo and should seek to establish multilateral security cooperation mechanisms.
Regional cooperation mechanisms would help prevent Japan from taking destabilizing military steps and lead the archipelago state to remain committed to its stated goal of making a “proactive” contribution to global peace.
“While looking at Japan’s security policy, South Korea needs to take into consideration all possibilities and scenarios. It should not be naive and should remain cool-headed,” said Nam Ki-jeong, a professor at the Institute for Japanese Studies at Seoul National University.
“What it can do is to work up diplomacy to lead Japan to move in the right direction within the multilateral security cooperation mechanism. The U.S., China and Russia can also get involved in the mechanism to promote the overall regional peace.”By Song Sang-ho (sshluck@heraldcorp.com)
-
Top 10 Most Significant Nvidia GPUs of All TimeSea level rise is worsening Hermine's coastal flooding茂名龙眼区域公用品牌LOGO正式发布Jeju Forum calls for Asian trust buildingApple's iPhone 17 will come with a huge RAM upgrade, report claimsEcho Dot (5th gen) deal — get it for $29.99 at AmazonLondon's nightlife is disappearing — here's why that's dangerous for the cityPrime exclusive deal: $50 off Govee floor lampWho is the Dark Wizard in 'The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power' Season 2?Hamilton rejects 'gamesmanship' claims in Hungarian GP pole fight
上一篇:I Deleted All My Social Accounts: Three Weeks Without Social Media
下一篇:A Journey Into the Mind of Stephen King
下一篇:A Journey Into the Mind of Stephen King
相关内容
- ·Spaceship tech slashes energy usage of existing AC systems
- ·市县联合开展保健食品科普宣传活动
- ·Tebas asks UEFA to revoke action against Super League trio
- ·Disney experiment lets you catch real objects while in VR
- ·中山古镇:到苏炳添家乡看“村BA”,来一场说走就走的美食之旅
- ·Tebas asks UEFA to revoke action against Super League trio
- ·N. Korea slams Japan's wastewater release from Fukushima power plant
- ·高州馆,百亿品牌底气!520奉上鲜荔
- ·“笋货”上市采购旺!清远西牛麻竹笋迎秋季尝鲜热
- ·S. Korea, U.S. devise principles against N.K. missiles
- ·Repairs to Verstappen car cost $1.8m: Horner
- ·Man United sign Sancho from Dortmund
- ·雨城区疾控中心提示:科学补碘 防治碘缺乏病
- ·London's nightlife is disappearing — here's why that's dangerous for the city
- ·#DeleteUber campaign inspired 500,000 to delete accounts in one week: NYTimes
- ·Udon is the heir to ramen's throne
最新内容
- ·24 of the Oldest Trees in the World
- ·Syrian table tennis player, 12, content despite defeat
- ·Milwaukee wins first NBA title since 1971
- ·Ahn confirms 2017 presidential bid
- ·Google Gemini now allows AI
- ·Djokovic loses Tokyo 2020 bronze
- ·Neighbors who thought they scored a free doormat were in for a gross surprise
- ·光华山隧道受损风机安全拆除
- ·South Korea beefs up drills amid escalating NK provocations
- ·出租车“霸占”公交车站台 此类不文明现象何时休
推荐内容
热点内容
- ·尝“鲜”盛宴,等你来探!2024年清远西牛麻竹笋尝鲜季即将启幕
- ·'Bitter' PSG face nemesis Lille in Tel Aviv
- ·创新“川渝智慧监管”新模式 服务民生增实效
- ·Voter turnout for N. Korea's local elections at 99.63%: KCNA
- ·What to expect when a tech bubble bursts
- ·Dressel claims Olympic freestyle crown for first individual gold
- ·Variety's email hacked, fake messages sent to readers
- ·市县联合开展保健食品科普宣传活动
- ·Military prosecutors indict intel official over leaking 'black agent' info
- ·Upsets in Olympic pool as Japan, Tunisia strike gold