[Pressure points] Should priority seating for pregnant women be kept empty?
Seoul Metro's trains have had priority seats reserved for pregnant women since 2013.
These pink seats, located at the ends of some rows, however, have been a source of continuous controversy. Recently, debate erupted online and in local media when one individual proposed that the city install a sensor system to prevent ineligible passengers from sitting in them, so they remain readily available in the event that a pregnant woman might need one.
Apart from practical issues associated with introducing such a sensor system, the debate has raised a lingering question that many have been pondering: Is it acceptable to sit in these seats until a pregnant woman boards the train?
Keep them empty
The proposal submitted to the Seoul Metropolitan Government’s online platform for policy proposals from residents on June 5 envisions sensor-activated alarms and lights that flash when anyone other than pregnant women occupy such seats.
The author of the proposal, identified only by the surname Kim, argues that currently the priority seats rely solely on the kindness of people, so they risk failing to fulfill their original purpose of accommodating those in need.
It would require a two-part system: a sensor to detect whether or not the priority seat is occupied and a card reader for pregnant women to tap their badge and confirm their pregnant status. If triggered, an alarm and warning message would prompt any passenger attempting to sit there: "Please tap your pregnant status badge."
Yoon Hye-mi, a Seoul resident in her 30s who is expecting in October, said that when a pink seat is occupied, she finds it awkward to ask the person to vacate.
"I've seen people occupying those seats, and even with my pregnancy badge, they simply ignore me, often engrossed in their phones. To avoid confrontation, I just stand during my commute,” Yoon said. “It would be nice if the seats were left empty.”
Lim Seo-yeon, a 31-year-old office worker living in Seoul, expressed a similar sentiment.
"I've used those seats when no others were available, thinking I would give up the seat immediately if a pregnant woman were to board the train," Lim said. "But for some pregnant women (without a badge), their condition might not be readily apparent. It was hard for me to tell."
Similar sentiments were expressed among The Korea Herald readers online.
"I was six months pregnant and took the subway, and one lady was sitting and didn’t even stand," a reader identified by the Instagram handle elotmani_siham08 said. "I am a foreigner, so I didn’t want to have any problems since I don’t speak Korean."
Another comment from Instagram user andiemelana echoed the opinion that the seat should be left empty: "Just like people shouldn’t park in disabled car park spots, why should they sit in the priority seat?"
There are also those who opposed the idea of installing sensor-activated alarms but still believe the seats should be left empty.
"I think the alarm is a stupid idea. It will only cause more hate toward pregnant women," said Gyeonggi Province resident Jang Hyun-joo, 33. "But I believe they should be left empty for pregnant women. Honestly, the number of priority seats don't seem enough to talk about efficiency."
'Everyone deserves a seat'
Many others indeed highlight the inefficiency of leaving the pink seats empty.
"Everyone deserves a seat on a crowded journey," said Park, a 40-something Seoul resident. "With the low birth rate, these seats often remain empty. Leaving them unoccupied seems like a waste."
One online commenter expressed frustration about the issue, according to a local news article: "I don't know why I pay my money to commute to and from work and have to feel guilty about sitting in an actual seat. Those policymakers are no help, coming up with useless ideas."
The government is also against mandating that the seats be left empty.
The Seoul Metropolitan Government acknowledges the frequent misuse of the priority seats, as evidenced by the number of complaints: 7,334 in 2022, 7,086 in 2023 and 2,421 for 2024 as of May. However, they express reservations about mandating that the seats be kept empty using alarms or other means.
"There's no legal basis to enforce exclusive use, and repetitive alarms could disturb other passengers,” the city said in a press release following the June 5 policy proposal.
Seoul Metro, which operates Subway Line Nos. 1-8, shares the concerns.
It emphasizes the importance of the current system being based on voluntary participation, similar to the general priority seating for vulnerable groups, and worries that Kim's proposal might exacerbate conflict between users.
"It might cause gender or generational conflict," a Seoul Metro official said.
"Pressure points" delves into the seemingly trivial, yet surprisingly contentious topics that ignite debate in our everyday lives. -- Ed.
-
Against All Odds: How Netflix Made ItAuthor Natasha Tynes may lose book deal after reporting a Metro employee for eating.Wolff hints at changes for survival of Monaco race庆国庆 学习强国积分可以这样用Pope says England are not 'oneLee vows to send special envoy to N. Korea, freeze public utility charges'The Good Place' got sloppy for a sports joke that made no senseHow to create a Facebook accountWorld’s first ‘meltdown国庆长假文明旅游温馨提示
- ·让法治建设成效更加可感可及
- ·充分挖掘运用红色资源 以红色培训推进党的理论教育和党性教育
- ·我市一人被评为9月“四川好人”
- ·Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 2 UK preorder listing leaks official price
- ·Get Thee to Totality: Chicago
- ·Expert insights: Leveraging South Korea's 105mm rounds to aid Ukraine
- ·Florida residents protesting mandatory masks is like a 'Parks and Rec' fever dream
- ·'American Crime Story: Impeachment' is a transfixing horror saga
- ·Number of COVID
- ·Moon, Yoon to hold luncheon on Wednesday
- ·Bromell, Thompson
- ·Thomas comeback seals PGA victory
- ·21 Unexpected Wonders in Colorado’s Vibrant Cities and Small Towns
- ·Moon, Yoon to hold luncheon on Wednesday
- ·我市一人被评为9月“四川好人”
- ·走进湘邻看纺织产业 如何实现智能化生产
- ·实干担当抓落实 多措并举促发展
- ·Exhibition showcases Indian chapter in Korean War
- ·YouTuber MrBeast's 'Finger on the App' challenge went for 70 hours
- ·Here are the 13 best tweets of the week
- ·World’s first ‘meltdown
- ·Alcaraz has 'confidence' to win Grand Slam
- ·Tesla says Juneteenth is a holiday, but Elon Musk clarifies the catch
- ·把群众放心上 确保政策执行不走样
- ·Number Representations in Computer Hardware
- ·庆国庆 学习强国积分可以这样用
- ·Giant dual
- ·Chelsea Manning released from jail after 62 days.
- ·France warm up for World Cup in Nations League
- ·Apple Watch 7 will be very hard to find at launch, report says
- ·18 Slightly Submerged Architectural Wonders
- ·Lee vows to send special envoy to N. Korea, freeze public utility charges
- ·兰开驰会见四川金强集团董事长周仕强
- ·Author Natasha Tynes may lose book deal after reporting a Metro employee for eating.
- ·10 Places to Get to Know Paul Bunyan
- ·Yoon says sure S. Korea